
As of today, 30th June 2021, the “loser pays” rule has been abolished for personal injury claims in Scotland. Until now, the pursuer (claimant) risked being found liable for the defender’s costs. The new rules remove that risk in most cases and mean defenders will be responsible for their own fees, unless the pursuer has acted “fraudulently, in a manifestly unreasonable manner or has abused the process”. In this article we’ll explain what is happening in more detail and discuss what this means for you.
New rules – what do they mean?
These new rules have been introduced on the back of the Civil Litigation (Expenses and Group Proceedings) (Scotland) Act 2018. “Loser pays” is, of course, the colloquial term for the matter. It is being replaced by the Qualified One Way Cost Shifting (QOCS) – the defender pays their own legal fees, in almost all cases. The 2018 Act has introduced numerous measures in the field of litigation. QOCS being that last to come into force.
The new rules notably have exceptions, but they are, at the moment, rather vague. Claimants will not face a finding of expenses if they lose their case, unless they have, in some way, acted “fraudulently, in a manifestly unreasonable manner or has abused the process”. These rules aren’t actually part of the 2018 Act, but have appeared in subsequent documents. This means that actual definitions for such conduct are yet to be decided. Whilst this, on the face of things, may seem worrying, it doesn’t have to be. In fact it is fairly common. Scotland is a common law jurisdiction, this means that part of our law is decided by judges. This means that the intricacies of the QOCS will be finessed in test cases over the next year, or so.
Is this a good thing?
These reforms were brought in on the back of Lord Gill’s Scottish Civil Court Review 2009 and Sheriff Principal Taylor’s Review of the Expenses and Funding of Civil Litigation in Scotland 2013. Those reviews concluded that inequalities in the system should be addressed. And this is why the Civil Litigation (EGP) (Scotland) Act 2018 was introduced.
The risk of pursuing a civil court action for damages and being left ‘out-of-pocket’ if that action is unsuccessful has been a long standing barrier for many claimants in taking action. An adverse finding of legal expenses is likely to hit an individual far harder than it would an insurance company or the company being sued. QOCS removes that barrier and improves access to justice for claimants.
Overall, these reforms should be viewed as a positive change. It’s important that our system recognises inequalities and promptly addresses them. This reform rebalances the power, in the claimant’s favour.
How can JHS LAW help?
Here at JHS LAW we pride ourselves on having a full-time specialist personal injury (PI) department. They have a wealth of experience in PI claims. We have the benefit of not only being specialist, but more importantly being local. Nick Gordon and Mark Marshall have 41 years experience in PI claims between them.
We are members of the Association of Personal Injury Lawyers and Action against Medical Accidents. We can handle any claim for damages against anyone who has caused you injury, through negligence.
If you have suffered as the result of an accident within the last three years (the usual time limit to apply), we can advise you as to your legal rights. We can assist you in recovering not only compensation for your physical and psychological pain and suffering, but also any financial loss you may have incurred, such as a loss of earnings to the past or future.
From our office in Dumfries, we are well placed to handle personal injury claims not only locally but throughout Scotland. We can guide you through all stages of the claim process. Should dispute resolution not be possible without litigation, we are experienced in all levels of Court matters – in both the Sheriff Courts and in the Court of Session.